Packing a Cooler for a Self-Catered Week on the Bay
Self-catering a week on Hooper's Island is one of the real pleasures of a big-house stay — the kitchen is built for group cooking, and there's nothing like a crab feast you made yourselves. Because the island is remote, though, the cooler you pack and the one big shop you do are what keep the week easy. Here's a simple strategy for arriving with everything cold, stocked, and ready to cook.
The cooler strategy for a long drive
If you're coming from a distance and bringing food from home, a good cooler setup earns its keep. Freeze solid freezer packs (or bottles of water) ahead of time rather than relying on loose ice, which melts fast and floods everything. Pack the coldest, most perishable items at the bottom against the packs, keep raw meat sealed and separate to avoid leaks, and open the cooler as little as possible on the road. A separate small cooler for drinks means the food cooler stays shut. Once you arrive, get perishables straight into the fridge — the house has a full kitchen waiting, so the cooler is really just your bridge across the drive.
What the kitchen already has
You're not cooking on a camp stove out here. The full kitchen has a large oven, a gas stove, granite counters, island seating for four, and a full breakfast room, so it's set up for real group meals. Coffee is handled by a Hamilton Beach 2-Way maker — brew ground coffee, or empty a K-Cup into the single-serve mesh basket — so just bring the coffee that fits it. Two things to note as you plan the cooking: there's no garbage disposal, so scrape plates into the trash, and the rear-deck smoker is an Oklahoma Joe's charcoal and wood offset, so if you want to smoke something, bring your own charcoal and wood (there's no propane).
The staples to bring — including oil and sugar
A well-equipped kitchen still isn't a stocked pantry, so a couple of basics need to come with you. Most importantly, bring your own cooking oil and your own sugar — these aren't provided, and they're exactly the things you don't want to discover missing mid-recipe when the nearest full grocery is about forty minutes away in Cambridge. A sensible bring-from-home list:
- Cooking oil and sugar — not stocked, bring what your menu needs
- Salt, pepper, and your go-to spices — plus Old Bay if you're doing a crab feast
- Coffee for the Hamilton Beach maker, plus filters if you use ground
- Charcoal and wood if you plan to run the offset smoker
- Foil, storage bags, and dish soap top-ups for a full week of cooking
Get $100 toward your first booking
Create a free Bayside Rewards account and we'll drop $100 toward your first direct booking — sign in when you check out and the $100 comes off there. Then earn 8% back on every stay after that.
The one big shop: Cambridge (~29 mi)
The anchor of your whole food plan is a single big supermarket run in Cambridge, about 29 miles from the house. This is where you buy the bulk of the week — produce, proteins, drinks, breakfast, snacks, and anything heavy you'd rather not carry from home. Doing it in one trip on the way in means you're not making the long round trip again mid-week. Then, for the freshest part of the menu, Rippons Brothers Seafood is just two miles away for crabs and local seafood, and The General Store about five miles off covers the last-minute gaps and has bug spray. Big shop in town, seafood close to home, General Store for the little misses — that's the whole system.
Cook, gather, repeat
The payoff for a bit of cooler discipline and one thorough shop is a week where the kitchen becomes the heart of the trip. Assign nights to different families, build one evening around a proper crab feast, keep a loose breakfast bar going in the breakfast room, and let dinners spill out to the pergola or the fire pit as the sun drops over the water. Self-catering out here isn't a compromise — done well, it's one of the best parts of the whole stay.